Just under a year ago, my life fell apart. After a decade and a half of marriage, my wife unceremoniously announced that it was over. I wasn’t faultless; I had failed my wife in a number of ways. And so I can’t really say her announcement came as a complete surprise. But it came as a complete surprise.
I was devastated by the news. Over the last year, I have struggled to come to grips with what I now refer to as “the new normal.” Of course, thousands of families fall apart every year. What may be unique about my experience is the role that board gaming has played in my ability to process, cope, and, to a degree, recover from this destabilizing event.
As some readers may know, I am one of the hosts, producers, and creators of a podcast focused on board games and relationships: Blue Peg, Pink Peg. At its conception, Blue Peg, Pink Peg’s central conceit was a discussion between two married couples about their board gaming experiences. While my marriage was marred by several issues that led to its dissolution, two things that always seemed to work were board gaming and podcasting. These interrelated passions unified and strengthened the bond between us. We enjoyed the distraction and pleasure provided by the former and the community and sense of shared purpose provided by the other.
In the wake of the initial split I was entirely at sea, unsure of many of the things that I had taken for granted for so many years. Relying upon the advice of innumerable books and internet “sages,” I threw myself into my hobbies, seeking both a focus and a distraction. Enter board games. Enter board games, big time.
During the first few weeks, I stayed with friends who pulled out a game to play almost every night. I could figure out the tumult in my life later. Meanwhile, I got to trade in the Mediterranean, fend off alien invaders, or run a power plant. For a few hours each night I could put the real out of my mind and bend my thoughts toward the imagined.
When the break happened, and it became incumbent for me to make the development known to the Blue Peg, Pink Peg listeners, I discovered how special the board game community is. My Board Game Geek inbox was flooded with messages of understanding and support.
Board games also served as a bridge for me and my children. Gaming reinstituted normalcy into our lives. It was during this time that my son discovered Magic: The Gathering, and he uses his hobby in much the same way I do, as an escape, a bonding experience, and a confidence-builder.
Finally, board games provided a template through which I was able to make sense of some of the emotions flooding through me and get my arms around some of the challenges with which I was being confronted. One thing I noticed in the months after my separation was that I was taking board games more seriously than I used to. I was starting to get upset when I lost games. Winning began to really matter, I realized, because I was starting to define myself through my game play. I was forced to acknowledge that I viewed myself as a failure. But this admission was necessary. It forced me to confront the many ways that I had failed myself, my former spouse, and my children, and set a course toward correcting the most pressing of my deficiencies. It also opened the door for me to forgive myself for my past failures and start to let go of the hurts that I still harbored.
Likewise, game play has helped me develop an ability to spot an obstacle and think through the various ways I might overcome it. In games, these challenges are always concrete. If you need to terraform the swamp space to desert before the neighboring dwarves terraform it to mountains, you can break down the various steps needed to reach that goal and the events that are likely to complicate your effort. While not every in-game challenge can be overcome, they can always be understood. In real life, this isn’t always the case. The greatest emotional challenge I faced after the separation was letting go of the hope that my spouse and I might reconcile. For months, I simply could not laid to rest that hope. Yet, after months of struggle, one night after a few great games of Concordia, I decided to sit down and quietly and methodically dissect my feelings.
During the gameplay earlier in the night, I was struck by how the game was, like many games, a web of interrelated choices. Some choices force you to abandon others. Sometimes your choices become limited or your opponent’s actions may profoundly frustrate your plans. However, a keen player is able to identify choices that open up more opportunities than they close.
For example, in Concordia players can choose to pursue what are referred to as “Minerva” cards. These cards pay off substantial benefits at the end of the game, provided the player is able to establish dominance in the regions that produce the good affiliated with a specific “Minerva” card. During that night’s game, a friend of mine often choose to select the linen “Minerva” card as soon as it became available, since this is the most valuable of these cards. However, after he claimed the linen card, the other players and I took actions that made it very difficult for him to establish a presence in the linen regions. Frustrated by our efforts, my friend eventually had to forgo his preferred tactic and pursue a different one.
In contrast, early in the same game, another one of my friends spent his energy diversifying his holdings, so that he was able to focus on the most productive routes to victory later in the game. Notably, he was able to make choices that gave him the freedom to adjust his tactics regardless of the board state on his turn.
During that game I realized, I had gone all-in on the linen “Minerva” card. I had framed my happiness through the lens of my marriage. All of my choices were directed toward one end, namely obtaining my former spouse’s love and approval. Everything I did was directed toward what I imagined to be her response. As I played, I realized that I needed to adopt more “routes to victory.”
After the game, I spent much of the remaining night laying out a list of things that would enrich my life and the steps that I could take to make those objectives possible. As a result, I was able to make the divorce less central to my life. This is not to say that I have successfully shifted my focus or exorcised the hope of reconciliation. As I said, viewing things through stark and concrete terms is only a starting point, but at least it was a starting point. And while I might have come to this conclusion on my own, my game playing experience served as a spark that helped me conceive of this challenge in concrete terms.
As alluded to earlier in this article, my journey is not over. Not even close. I still struggle every day with difficulties, some large, some small, some new, some old. While I draw upon various resources to get through those challenges, board games and the gaming community remain a resource upon which I can rely to make the hard times a little bit easier.
I went through a similar situation about three years ago. I was an avid gamer in my youth – more Avalon Hill and the like – but turned to the new breed of board games to further a relationship with my twin daughters. It gave us an activity that was all our own. They were 6 at the time and are just turning 9 now. From Catan and Carcassonne as early entries we now enjoy Friday nights of Terra Mystica and Agricola. While they can’t seem to get their friends involved the three of us have formed our own nice gaming group.
Hang in there, I promise things do get easier. You have the love of a great community around you.
This is one of the most touching and profound articles I’ve read in years (board games or otherwise). Thank you for sharing, Patrick. I’ve never been married, but the things you talk about here will sit with me for a long time.
Coming up on one-year anniversary of my divorce, and wow, this really hit home. Nice work.
Profound and insightful. My husband and I have discovered the cathartic aspect of our gaming hobby this summer as my mother-in-law was battling cancer. We were able to enjoy several memorable games of Telestrations with her before she passed. And then gaming provided distraction and healing in bringing the large extended family back together again. Thanks, Patrick, for speaking honestly.
Man, what an article. I connected so well with what you wrote. Thank you for taking the time to write this. Very helpful for some of us others who are struggling as well.
One of the things I love about you Patrick is your heartfelt, raw transparency. Not many are able to go there and be real. Tying in the hobby and articulating how it has helped you not only find an outlet, but evaluate the things in your life you want to improve on seems so healthy and helpful to others. You are a quality person and I for for one am glad to know you. Wish you all the best on this journey.
Beautifully articulated. As an avid listener to your podcast, I feel that in many ways I (in some intangible ways) know you guys and I am praying for you and your family.
Board gaming has been a real way that I have bonded with my own wife and our five kids. My teenage daughter attempted suicide two years ago and it made me realize that we needed to connect more as a family. We had played Catan some, but after my daughter came home from the hospital, we expanded our library. We now play games at least twice a week and it has made our family (and our daughter) stronger and more connected.
Thank you all at BPPP for sharing your passions and lives with us. I know that your podcast has made my life better (never would have played Voluspa without you :). I wish you nothing but happiness and peace.
To all of you that have responded to this article, thank you. It means a great deal to hear from so many of you, some of who have shared very touching tales of your own. To all of you, I send my warmest regards and greatest hopes. To those of you that I know personally, your kind words mean so much to me. Actually, the same can be said of all of you. I count you all as friends I have yet to meet.
I really feel that games (and play generally) can do a great deal to heal, help, teach, and connect us. I have other stories to tell, along these lines, and hope to have them written soon. And as I said in the article, my story is not over. In fact, our story is not over. There is light on every horizon.
you are in reality a excellent webmaster. The web site loading pace is incredible.
It kind of feels that you’re doing any unique trick.
Furthermore, The contents are masterwork. you have done a excellent
task on this matter!